Firing someone is one of the hardest things you will ever do as a manager, especially when they are just not cutting it performance-wise. Figuring out how to terminate an employee for poor performance means finding that balance between protecting your company and treating people with basic dignity. A good Employee termination process isn’t just crossing t’s and dotting i’s—it’s a strategic move that maintains workplace integrity and keeps legal headaches at bay. When you’re dealing with Termination for poor performance, following established steps isn’t optional—it’s essential for fairness and transparency.
What matters here:
- Keeping solid records of performance issues as they happen
- Having regular, honest conversations about what is working and what’s not
- Being crystal clear about expectations and what happens if they are not met
Having a solid Performance-based termination policy sets standards everyone understands and gives managers the confidence to address problems before they snowball. And making sure you follow Legal termination in India guidelines protects your organization from potential nightmares while ensuring everything is done ethically and legally. This guide walks you through handling these tough situations with care, emphasizing how important it is to do your homework and communicate respectfully. When you integrate these practices, you build a culture where accountability matters, and performance issues get addressed in ways that are both human and compliant. Read our other article: How to File for Design Protection in India: Step-by-Step Process & Requirements.
Understanding the Legal Aspects of Employee Termination
Managing the issue of poor performance as an employee breach is a sensitive problem requiring legal compliance, fairness, and transparency in terminating the employee. Various labour laws in India govern termination of employment, and the aspect of non-compliance gives rise to wrongful termination claims or litigation. The employee termination process: what every organization must know.
Major Indian Statutes Regulating Termination
In India, termination for poor performance is governed by various legal provisions. If these laws are not complied with, termination in India would be illegal, leading to unnecessary disputes which employers must avoid.
| Law | Applicability | Key Termination Provisions |
| The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 | Industry and service workers | Prohibits arbitrary termination only, subject to benefits notice |
| Shops and Establishments Act | Service workers | Procedural regulations for termination |
| Employment contract law | All workers with employment contracts | What could allow performance-based termination and severance pay |
Laws Applicable to the Termination of an Employee in India
To comply, employers must take these actions in implementing a performance-based termination policy:
- Give Written Warnings: Employees should get written notices of their poor performance before their termination, giving them a chance to improve.
- Structured PIP: Set up a formal PIP to use before termination.
- Document Everything: Keep meticulous notes on employee performance, feedback, and disciplinary actions.
- Give Notice: Employees must be given a 30- to 90-day notice unless terminated for gross misconduct as per legal requirements.
- Pay Final Settlement and Severance (if applicable): Employers should pay off dues like unpaid salary, bonuses and gratuity before the exit.
If employers do not adhere to the legal processes, they could face wrongful dismissal claims, legal action, or reputational damage.
Identifying and Documenting Poor Performance
When in doubt, DO NOT fire your employees. Before you do, make sure you have established definitively the guidelines for poor performance, have given the employee ample time to correct, and have records of EVERYTHING. This prevents termination in India without legal compliance and minimizes disputes between employees and legal risks.
Definition: Problems Performance
Poor performance is not a one-off mistake; it is a pattern of consistently falling short of the job requirements. Performance Issues Must be Assessed Objectively Against Measurable Criteria
One common example of a bad performance includes:
- Not Meeting KPIs — Failing to hit established targets, deadlines, or quality standards consistently.
- Underperformance – Low productivity versus peers or against company metrics.
These Are Examples of Mistakes I Have Not Made:
- Negative Attitude & Lack of Initiative – Resistance to feedback, refusal to improve, or being disengaged from work.
Tracking and documenting performance
Documentation of an employee’s performance issues is important for:
- Creating a well-defined performance history
- Serving as proof in the event of legal disputes
- Determine the legal basis of the termination.
- How to avoid wrongful termination claims
Best Practices to Follow When Documenting Performance Problems
| Step | Action | Purpose |
| Step 1: Set Clear Expectations | Define measurable KPIs and performance goals. | Guides employees in knowing what they need to do. |
| Step 2: Give Continuous Feedback | From both structured and unstructured reviews. | Informs employees of an opportunity for improvement before being let go |
| Step 3: Give Verbal & Written Warnings | Document each warning and conversation. | 6 creates a history of unsupported choices. |
| Step 4: Create a PIP | Put the employee where it matters — on paper. | Shows that the employer tried to assist. |
| Step 5: Perform a Final Review Before Termination | Assess whether performance has improved after PIP. | Justifies terminating employment if there are no improvements. |
Role of Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) Before Termination
A performance improvement plan (PIP) is a formalized process that allows an employee having trouble working to take one last chance of improving before facing termination. It sets clear goals, timelines, and expectations.
Key Elements of a PIP
- General Problems: Outline specific areas of underperformance clearly.
- Defined Goals: Outline measurable targets that the employee will have to meet.
- Time Frame: Set a realistic time frame (30-90 days) during which improvement is expected.
- Support & Training: Providing support such as training or mentoring.
- Consequences: What happens if the employee does not turn it around?
That gives the employee the chance to walk away from the company, if necessary, rather than being fired, and the employer the option to fire the employee for not meeting goals, while still being compliant with company policies and labor laws.
Implementing a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)
In the context of the employee termination process for poor performance, the application of a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) is a vital part of the employee termination process. Having a detailed PIP not only provides the guideline for improvement but also makes it clear that every attempt to help the employee excel would be taken before alignment with dismissal. Secondly, it creates a strong basis for termination for cause in India, should the employee not meet the benchmarks set during counselling.
What is a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)?
A PIP is an official document that specifies how an employee’s performance is falling short of organizational expectations; it defines specific, quantifiable goals for improvement. It is designed to:
- Set clear expectations and performance standards.
- Take action to set a defined time frame for the employee to remedy any deficiencies.
- Kept as documented proof of the actions taken before deciding how to terminate an employee for poor performance.
This way, this process is constructive, transparent, and gives the employee fair chances to correct his practices while you have evidences in hand to defend your organization from any legal issues in the future.
Writing a PIP with Goals that You Can Measure
Clarity and effectiveness of a PIP depend on a structured approach to PIP. If you want to build one, here are the key imagination ingredients:
- Define Specific Performance Metrics: Define specific Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that the employee should meet.
- Defined Timelines: Establish a clear and reasonable window — typically 30 to 90 days — in which the employee needs to demonstrate substantial progress.
- Clear Expectation: Clearly explain the expectations that are not being met and what the changes should be.
- Support Mechanisms: Describe any training, mentoring, or means put in place to assist the employee in achieving these targets.
- Regular Check-ins: Set dates for reviews and feedback.
Through this structured process, it bolsters the integrity of the employee termination process for poor performance and gives you hard evidence for support of a decision if the employee is unable or unwilling to improve.
Tracking Progress and Providing Support
After starting that PIP, you gotta keep an eye on how they are doing. Most managers mess this up by not being consistent.
- Numbers don’t lie: Track their actual results against targets. Just raw data, no sugar-coating.
- Regular sit-downs: Grab coffee weekly and cut through the BS. Ask them straight up what is working and what’s not.
- Keep records of everything: Every training session, every resource, every bit of extra help. Not just to cover your ass (though that helps) but to see what is making a difference.
This tracking stuff does not have to be complicated:
| What to Do | Why Bother | Real Life Example |
| Track Results | See if they’re getting better | “Hey, let’s grab coffee on Thursday and talk about how that project’s going” |
| Weekly Check-ins | Get to the real issues | Save emails about training sessions and notes from your coaching sessions |
| Document Help | Prove you tried everything | “Hey, let’s grab coffee on Thursday and talk about how that project’s going.” |
If they still suck after all that effort, at least you know you tried.
When a PIP Fails—Deciding on Termination
Sometimes people just do not work out despite everything. Here is when you know it’s time:
- The data tells the story: Their numbers have not budged after weeks of help.
- Watch their attitude: They are making excuses instead of trying harder.
- Look at your team: Other people are getting frustrated picking up the slack.
- Cover yourself: Make sure everything’s documented and HR knows what is happening.
When you finally do have to fire them, keep it short and direct. No big surprise since you have been talking about their performance for weeks. Firing people sucks. But dragging it out when someone clearly can’t cut it just makes everyone miserable longer.
Preparing for the Employee Termination Process
Preparing to go through the employee termination process for poor performance is the important stage that addresses the fact that all actions are legal, ethical, and properly documented. Thus, a properly drafted well-organized plan would assist a legal termination in India & would further strengthen the termination policy based on performance, well above how to terminate an employee for poor performance.
Involve HR and legal departments
When initiating the employee termination process for poor performance, it is essential to work collaboratively with your HR and legal teams. This step makes the process rigorous and defensible:
- Assess the Situation: Before jumping to conclusions, review performance records, previous warnings, and feedback to ensure that the problems are systemic.
- Develop a Strategy: Establish who you will be firing for poor performance and devise a clear plan to do so, by what is permissible according to your company policy
- Compliance Assurance: Make sure no steps are taken that can legally entangle the entity in India.
- Plan the Communication: Plan how the communication will happen and in what tone, when, and in which venue, to ensure dignity and clarity are maintained.
- Seek Approvals: Obtain endorsements from legal advisors and HR heads to move forward confidently.
Collecting Essential Documentation for Compliance
Carefully documenting is the foundation of a defensible termination process. This step is to gather all the evidence that will prove the decision:
- Performance Records: Collect performance evaluations, warnings, and any recorded feedback showcasing underperformance.
- Communication Logs: Keep a log of any emails, meeting notes, and conversations regarding performance issues.
- Legal Documentation: You have access to queries designed to help you in gathering signed policies, joint, or any legal opinions that confirm the business complies with labor laws.
- Audit Trail: Prepare a chronology of events surrounding the termination to give the appearance of a fair process.
- Employee Acknowledgements: Note any recognition by the employee of the issues that have been discussed.
Creating a Termination Checklist for Poor Performance
To cover every step of termination, a detailed and carefully planned process is crucial to ensure that nothing falls through the cracks. This checklist serves as a guide throughout the employee termination process for poor performance:
| Checklist Item | Details |
| Pre-Termination Review | Complete all performance reviews, HR consults, etc. |
| Legal Approval | Confirm compliance with labor laws and internal policies |
| Termination Meeting Agenda | Prepare key points for discussion, reasoning for cancellation, and follow-up. |
| Asset Recovery | List and fetch company assets (ID cards, laptops, etc.). |
| Final Settlement | Calculate and prepare details for severance pay, unpaid salary, and benefits. |
Every single point is domestic and extracts each dimension in the performance-based termination policy approach that must be clear, effective, and useful.
Issuing Severance Package, Due Settlement, and Notice Period
Ending financial commitments and notice periods are an important part of this process:
- Calculate Severance Pay: Consider severance pay based on tenure, role, and company policy for fairness.
- Go through Final Settlement — Determine all pending dues — Salary, bonus, which is due, and any accumulated benefits.
- Comply with Notice Period: Ensure the termination is in line with the contractual or legally required notice period.
- Write It All Down: Have a detailed record of everything from financial calculations to any communication to avoid future disputes.
- Be clear with your communication: Communicate and explain the final settlement, timelines, and the process to the employee, so that there is no ambiguity.
Conducting the Termination Meeting Professionally
The termination meeting (if done well) is the last step in the termination process for poor performance, but arguably the most important. This meeting should be conducted meticulously to prevent miscommunication and legal issues, and to ensure that the organization adheres to an obvious termination policy based on performance. This should be consistent with HR best practices and the legal characteristics of a legal termination in India and instruct managers on how to terminate an employee for poor performance, without spiralling into undue contention.
Deciding When, and Where.
- Neutral and Private Setting:
Ensure an option where the meeting can occur in a private and protected setting. It helps to minimize stress and avoid unnecessary interruptions. - Right Timing:
Set a time for the meeting that receives the least amount of public attention (such as at the end of the day) to show respect and discretion.
Determining Attendees
- Key Participants:
A senior manager, an HR representative, and, if necessary, an advisor from the legal department. This will give you something of a balanced viewpoint and shows that you were following the employee termination procedure. - Clear Roles:
Every participant should know their role—HR prepares documents, the manager describes performance challenges, and the legal advisor ensures that the termination is done as per the law in India.
Communication Strategy
- Clarity and Empathy:
Express this decision using clear language, but balance it with compassion. Cite the specific reasons for the termination and refer to documented performance issues. - Structured Script:
Use a script that you have prepared that contains:- Processing time: An introduction on why we were there.For those joining late, a snapshot of the performance issues and what has been done so far.
- A straightforward statement that the decision to terminate was based on termination for poor performance.
Avoiding Emotional Reactions and Legal Missteps
- Maintain Professionalism:
The tone must remain neutral. Do not use emotional language that the reader may misinterpret. - Legal and Ethical Consistency:
Rely on facts and established performance data. Avoid subjective statements and keep every statement consistent with the performance-based termination policy.
Handling Post-Termination Procedures
After the termination meeting, the termination of the employee can be an important part of addressing employees effectively. This phase serves multiple purposes, such as solidifying the back-end side of handling the transition, as well as protecting the stance of the closing organization. A solid performance management and termination policy should adhere to the following steps to support a legally sustainable termination in India.
Closing Paperwork and Settlements
- Full & Final Settlement:
Next, create a complete documentation of the final settlement for the employee. Add to this your salary, bonus, leave encashment, and applicable severance pay. - Relieving Letter and Paperwork:
Issue a relieving letter stating the termination, along with all other paperwork, ensuring that written communications are as per the record.
Retrieving Company Assets and Access Credentials
- Asset Recovery Process:
Identify and retrieve all company property in the employee’s possession, including identification badges, laptops, mobile devices, and keys or access passes. - Access Revocation:
To protect organizational data, it is crucial to immediately terminate your employee’s access to company systems and data.
Communicating the Decision to the Team
- Internal Communication:
Communicate the departure to other teams in a way that is respectful and informative without sharing sensitive details. - Maintaining Morale:
Make it clear that the decision was made by the business’s performance-based termination policy and reaffirm the commitment to professional standards within the organization.
Helping with Career Transitions
- Outplacement Assistance:
Where appropriate, provide outplacement services such as resume workshops, interview coaching, or job placement services. Not only does this work in favour of the leaving employee but also helps keeping the image of the company as a responsible employer intact. - Post-Exit Follow-Up:
Offer to schedule a meeting to follow up, or provide a point of contact for any questions about the termination post-decision, to help the transition go smoothly.
Employee Rights in Performance-Based Termination
Yours has a good understanding of employee rights under a performance-based termination policy. Yes, even during the employee termination process, when you are facing termination due to poor performance, people deserve rights and clarity. This handbook provides an overview of important rights and the statutory matrix for legal termination in India for the use of both the employer and employee.
Overview of Employee Rights
- Due Process: Employees should be informed of performance issues with documentation and allowed to respond.
- Open Communication: Honesty is critical in clearly explaining why someone is being terminated.
- Fairness: Decisions should be based on objective, measurable performance standards.
- Formal grievance and appeal mechanisms serve as essential opportunities for appeal for employees.
- Legal Protection: Outlining how to terminate an employee for poor performance helps to protect both parties involved.
The Legal Framework and Documentation
- Compliance with laws: Labour laws of the land shall apply for effective termination in India.
- Documentation: Keep records of performance reviews, warnings, and communications.
- Rely on objective criteria: Base decisions on measurable metrics of performance.
Mechanisms for Appeal and Grievance
- Formal Appeal Process: Outline a process for employees to appeal termination decisions.
- Guardianship: Create transparent means for dispute resolution.
FAQ
Q1: What are the legal considerations when terminating an employee for poor performance?
Labor laws require employers to comply with statutory labor practices, including due process, proper documentation, and that an employee is made aware before termination. Hence, it is imperative to speak with HR and legal experts to avoid wrongful termination claims; also, termination is undertaken per the legal termination in India.
Q2: How to document poor performance before termination?
You want your documentation to include as much detailed records as possible, such as performance reviews, warning letters, feedback sessions outlining expectations, and any Performance Improvement Plans (PIP) that may have been implemented. Having such records is extremely important; they are proof of how the termination decision was made based on objective criteria and within a well-structured process of employee termination.
Q3: What steps should be taken before terminating an employee?
Before termination, employers should conduct standard performance reviews, clarify the performance problem, issue formal warnings, and, if necessary, offer a PIP. By providing an opportunity for improvement in these steps, this is the basis for a performance-related dismissal.
Q4: Can an employee be fired without warning for poor performance?
Employees should not be fired without prior notice in most cases as they ought to be allowed to fix and improve performance issues. In extreme circumstances, termination without any prior notice may be required, but omitting a strict warning sequence puts the company at risk of legal action.
Q5. How to professionally conduct a termination meeting?
You should hold a termination meeting in a private, neutral location (HR (human resources) should also be present, and if necessary, a legal advisor). The dialogue needs to be clear, data driven, and respectful of the individual while addressing proven performance deficiencies, without any emotional flavouring, so the whole exercise appears to be part of a structured employee termination process.
Q6: What severance package should be offered for performance-based termination?
A severance package can be determined according to the employee’s length of service, position, and the firm’s policy, covering any unpaid salary, benefits accrued up to the end date, and payment instead of notice. It is fair, adheres to local employment rules, and is clearly and effectively communicated to the employees, to help avoid the risk of disputes.
Q7: How to avoid wrongful termination lawsuits?
To avoid wrongful termination lawsuits, make sure to follow all legal processes, document everything you do and can, issue a final warning, including who was involved in the decision, and make sure your decisions are based on actual performance data or metrics. A solid performance-based termination policy requires consistent consultation with legal and HR professionals.
Conclusion
In short, managing termination for underperformance also requires an orderly and ethical employee termination in line with the process that honors both the legal requirements along the respect of the person. If you are getting fired, then this should also be followed to ensure that if your situation warrants termination, all steps from documenting the poor performance to holding the meeting are properly backed up with sound evidence and processes. Abiding by the legal termination standards in India is of utmost importance so that the organization can steer clear of wrongful termination claims as well as to protect the organization’s image.
Some of the strategies talk about documentation, due process, communication, etc. With these steps in hand, employers can guide themselves through the nuances of how to fire an employee for performance issues, ensuring workplace culture remains intact and legal compliance is guaranteed.
Fairness and transparency are paramount for those having to make these tough decisions. Additional guidance can certainly be sought by consulting with HR experts first, or legal counsel can help ensure that every step of the entire process is taken care of appropriately.
About Us
Corrida Legal is a boutique corporate & employment law firm serving as a strategic partner to businesses by helping them navigate transactions, fundraising-investor readiness, operational contracts, workforce management, data privacy, and disputes. The firm provides specialized and end-to-end corporate & employment law solutions, thereby eliminating the need for multiple law firm engagements. We are actively working on transactional drafting & advisory, operational & employment-related contracts, POSH, HR & data privacy-related compliances and audits, India-entry strategy & incorporation, statutory and labour law-related licenses, and registrations, and we defend our clients before all Indian courts to ensure seamless operations.
We keep our client’s future-ready by ensuring compliance with the upcoming Indian Labour codes on Wages, Industrial Relations, Social Security, Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions – and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. With offices across India including Gurgaon, Mumbai and Delhi coupled with global partnerships with international law firms in Dubai, Singapore, the United Kingdom, and the USA, we are the preferred law firm for India entry and international business setups. Reach out to us on LinkedIn or contact us at contact@corridalegal.com/+91-9211410147 in case you require any legal assistance. Visit our publications page for detailed articles on contemporary legal issues and updates.