Introduction
Did you know that the redundancy of a pregnant employee may be illegal under India’s new labour laws? Pregnant employees are entitled to strong legal protection against wrongful termination, unfair dismissal, and workplace discrimination in India. Unfortunately, many employers misunderstand or overlook the protections provided to pregnant women and mothers, making them vulnerable to redundancy.
This job security during pregnancy is protected under the Maternity Benefit Act, of 1961, which provides paid maternity leave, job security, and safeguards against termination during pregnancy. Some organizations try to get around these laws, using excuses like redundancy or cost cutting as the justification for termination. Not only is this ethically ambiguous, it can also be legally contested under Indian labour laws.
This article will cover:
- What constitutes redundancy, and is it legal?
- Protections for pregnant employees under key employment laws.
- Employer responsibilities and valid grounds for redundancy.
- Legal action against unfair redundancies.
- Established laws protecting pregnant workers.
- Steps that pregnant employees can take to protect themselves.
By the end of this article, you will know exactly what your rights are if you find yourself in this situation, and what actions you can take.
What is Redundancy? Is this legal for Expecting Employees?
Understanding Redundancy in India
Redundancy, in the context of employment law, describes a state in which a company terminates employee’s position due to budgetary issues, reorganization, or technology. It is distinct from termination for cause or poor performance.
However, where redundancy is used as an excuse to dismiss pregnant employees, this can be considered as both unlawful and discriminatory.
Is it legal to make Pregnant Employees Redundant in India?
- No, a pregnant employee cannot be made redundant on the grounds of her pregnancy.
- As per the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, dismissing a woman during the maternity leave period is illegal.
- Employers must have a genuine and serious reason for making people redundant, which is not discriminatory.
- This could constitute unlawful discrimination, if redundancy disproportionately impacts pregnant employees.
Legal Protections for Pregnant Employees from Redundancy
1. Maternity Benefit Act, 1961
In India, the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, is the most significant piece of legislation that safeguards a pregnant woman’s right not be made redundant.
Key Provisions:
- It prevents dismissal during maternity leave.
- Offers 26 weeks of fully paid maternity leave to eligible employees.
- Job security after returning from maternity leave.
- Protects pregnant workers from being terminated without just cause.
2. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
- Employers cannot retrench pregnant employees on a whim.
- Any retrenchment must go through due process, along with severance compensation.
3. Equal Remuneration Act, 1976
- Prohibits discrimination based on gender in employment.
- Guarantees equal pay and equal employment protections for women, including pregnancy-related job security.
Employers’ Responsibilities to Pregnant Employees
What Must Employers Do?
Employers must:
- Provide maternity leave and benefits under the Maternity Benefit Act.
- Prohibit discrimination against pregnant workers.
- Follow appropriate redundancy processes, including justification and severance.
- Ensure no biased selection criteria for redundancy.
- Provide the employee a fair chance to return after maternity leave.
What Employers Cannot Do?
- Dismiss a pregnant employee.
- Use redundancy as a smokescreen for discrimination.
- Refuse maternity benefits or cut pay.
- Make an employee work instead of the statutory notice period.
Pregnant Employees Facing Redundancy: Legal Pathways
| Legal Remedy | What It Entails |
| The Fine Line Between Employee and Independent Contractor | To report the termination discrimination, you need to file a complaint against the employer. |
| Requesting Restitution and Back Pay | Labor courts can order the employer to reinstate the employee and compensate wages lost during the suspension. |
| Resorting to the National/State Commission for Women | If the redundancy is gender discriminatory, employees can approach these commissions with their grievances. |
| Legal Action in Court | Employees can file a suit for wrongful termination and seek damages for emotional distress, loss of income, and discrimination. |
Can You Lay Off a Pregnant Employee?
Before we address the question of whether a pregnant employee can be retrenched, let us delve into the employment rights under Indian labour laws. Redundancy, as such, is legal if it is genuine, non-discriminatory, and carried out by the statutory protections under different laws such as the Maternity Benefit Act, of 1961, and the Industrial Disputes Act, of 1947.
Real-Life Instances Where Redundancy is Real and Legal
Employers can legally apply for redundancy under certain circumstances, if this is not specifically directed at a pregnant employee. Real redundancy usually occurs under the following circumstances:
- Business Closure: If the business permanently ceases operations, redundancy for its employees, including pregnant women, is applicable.
- Departmental Shutdown: Redundancy may be lawful if a specific department or function is closed, rendering certain positions superfluous.
- Financial Situation: Companies struggling through critical financial conditions may reduce employment, as long as they are not unfairly targeting pregnant employees.
- Technological Changes: If a job becomes redundant due to automation and no suitable alternative role is available, redundancy is valid.
Example: if a company automates its HR department and lays off all HR workers, including pregnant workers, that would seem like a legitimate redundancy scenario. However, it raises legal issues if the pregnant employee is the only one who has been terminated.
No Bias Against Pregnant Employees – Requirement for Fair Selection Criteria
Even in cases of genuine redundancy, an employer must use fair, transparent, and objective selection criteria that do not disadvantage pregnant employees.
Selection Criteria Must Be Neutral
- Pregnant employees cannot be included in redundancy targeted selection.
- Any selection or assessment matrix should be based on the objective business needs.
- If redundancies are the only option, it must be done to the same extent to all employees within the department affected.
Illegal Discriminatory Practices
- Automatically placing pregnant employees on redundancy lists.
- Requiring a pregnant worker to leave and hiring a temporary replacement as a means of denying maternity leave benefits.
- Failing to provide translational roles when available in the organization.
Example: A corporation should not dismiss or lay off only pregnant employees, but rather apply neutral performance-based criteria (e.g. last-in-first-out, skill set requirements).
Employer required to substantiate justification for redundancy on business necessity and non-discriminatory basis
Redundancy is only fair when employers demonstrate that:
- It is solely for legitimate business needs.
- It is not based on an employee’s pregnancy status.
- It must be fairly applied across the workforce.
Lack of clear, lawful reason for redundancy may result in:
- A lawsuit for wrongful termination.
- A labour court for reinstatement, along with back pay.
- Penalties and fines for violations of labour laws.
Example: A manufacturing company that has seen a downturn in demand might lay off several employees. However, if only pregnant employees are involuntarily terminated, it is illegal and subject to litigation.
Judicial Precedents and Case Laws to Define Fair Dismissal.
Indian courts have consistently held that pregnant employees cannot be wrongfully subjected to redundancy. Strong case laws have laid down the law:
- Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Female Workers (2000):
The Supreme Court ruled that all maternity-related benefits must be extended even to contract workers, reiterating that redundancy or termination cannot be based on a worker’s pregnancy. - Nargesh Meerza v. Air India (1981):
The court held that any employment policy discriminatory to women for pregnancy is unconstitutional. Pregnancy must not affect employment security. - Neera Mathur v. Life Insurance Corporation of India (1992):
The Supreme Court ruled that employers cannot seek sensitive pregnancy information, reinforcing privacy and job security protections for pregnant workers.
These decisions highlight that pregnancy must not be considered a liability, and the employer must ensure its redundancy practices are fair.
If You Are Pregnant and Made Redundant What Should an Employee Do?
An employee who is pregnant and at risk of redundancy should:
- Request a written explanation from the employer for redundancy.
- Maintain written records of all communications regarding termination.
- File a complaint with the labour commissioner under the Maternity Benefit Act of 1961.
- Consult a labour lawyer to assess possible legal options.
- If redundancy seems discriminatory, seek help from the State or National Commission for Women.
Redundancies should never be accepted at face value by pregnant employees. Know your rights and fight back against wrongful termination.
Important Judgements on Pregnancy and Redundancy in India
1️. Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Female Workers (2000)
- “Whoever earns four for eight should be compensated for maternity” – Supreme Court.
2️. Air India v. Nargesh Meerza (1981)
- The court struck down discriminatory service conditions that punished women for pregnancy.
What Pregnant Employees Can Do to Protect Their Rights
- Understand their rights legally before you tell your boss you’re pregnant.
- Record all communications regarding the maternity leave and redundancy decisions.
- Consult a labour lawyer before signing any termination agreement.
- Report unfair redundancy to labour authorities.
FAQs on Legal Protections of Pregnant Employees:
1. Can a company terminate a pregnant employee for cost-cutting reasons?
Not if cost-cutting disproportionately affects pregnant employees. Redundancy must be supported by solid evidence.
2. What should I do if my employer does not give me maternity benefits?
In case of non-compliance, you can file a complaint with the labour commissioner or take legal action under the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961.
3. Can I take legal action if I am dismissed while on maternity leave?
Yes, termination during maternity leave is strictly forbidden under the Maternity Benefit Act. You request reinstatement, or seek financial compensation.
Conclusion
The Maternity (Amendment) Benefits Act, Industrial Disputes Act, and Equal Remuneration Act protect pregnant employees against redundancy and wrongful dismissal. An employer cannot dismiss the employee simply for being pregnant or taking maternity leave.
Pregnant employees must document everything, consult a lawyer, and file a claim with the labour commissioner.
About Us
Corrida Legal is a boutique corporate & employment law firm serving as a strategic partner to businesses by helping them navigate transactions, fundraising-investor readiness, operational contracts, workforce management, data privacy, and disputes. The firm provides specialized and end-to-end corporate & employment law solutions, thereby eliminating the need for multiple law firm engagements. We are actively working on transactional drafting & advisory, operational & employment-related contracts, POSH, HR & data privacy-related compliances and audits, India-entry strategy & incorporation, statutory and labour law-related licenses, and registrations, and we defend our clients before all Indian courts to ensure seamless operations.
We keep our clients future-ready by ensuring compliance with the upcoming Indian Labour codes on Wages, Industrial Relations, Social Security, Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions – and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, of 2023. With offices across India including Gurgaon, Mumbai, and Delhi coupled with global partnerships with international law firms in Dubai, Singapore, the United Kingdom, and the USA, we are the preferred law firm for India entry and international business setups. Reach out to us on LinkedIn or contact us at contact@corridalegal.com/+91-8826680614 in case you require any legal assistance. Visit our publications page for detailed articles on contemporary legal issues and updates.