Understanding Anticipatory Breach in India

Q: What happens if both parties expect a breach?

In the event that both parties indicate that they are unable to fulfill their obligations, the contract can potentially be terminated by mutual agreement.

Introduction

Contracts are important in both personal interaction and business interaction, ensuring that parties fulfill their commitments in a legally binding manner. However, what happens if one party, before the performance is due, states that they cannot or will not fulfill their obligations? This situation is known as an anticipatory breach of contract.

Section 39 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 deals with anticipatory breach in India. This provision grants the non-defaulting party a right to immediately terminate the contract and seek remedies, or to wait until the time for performance arrives before taking action.

What is an Anticipatory Breach of Contract?

An anticipatory breach occurs when one party indicates its intention not to perform its contractual duties before the time for performance. The refusal can be explicit or implied. This means that it is already deemed a breach, even if the time for performance has not passed.

For instance, if a company executes a contract to supply raw materials by the 1st of the next month, however, later sends written communication stating that they will not be able to supply the materials, it is an anticipatory breach of contract.

What is the Importance of Anticipatory Breach?

There are a few reasons why the legal doctrine of anticipatory breach of contract is important:

Permits Early Legal Action – The non-breaching party can sue or take remedial steps immediately instead of waiting until the due date.
Mitigates Business Losses – If performance under a contract is crucial for a business, the affected party can make alternative arrangements to minimize losses.
Empowers the Enforcement of Contracts – By making parties accountable for their commitments and performance before the date of delivery, it prevents last-minute defaults and ensures reliability in contractual commitments.

This article discusses the relevant legal provisions, the implications, case laws & remedies available in case of anticipatory breach of contract in India.

Legal Framework for Anticipatory Breach in India

Section 39 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872

Contract law in India is governed by the Indian Contract Act, 1872, which includes provisions regarding the breach of contracts. Section 39 of the Act states:

“When a promisor repudiates or indicates an inability or unwillingness to perform a contract in its entirety, the promisee may terminate the contract unless he has indicated, by words or conduct, an assent to its continuation.”

This means that if one of the parties to the contract indicates their unwillingness to perform or is not capable of performing the contract, the other party has a legal right to rescind the contract and seek damages.

When Does an Anticipatory Breach Occur?

An anticipatory breach takes place when:

Breach – One party explicitly refuses to fulfill its contractual obligations.
Preventing Performance — One party does something that makes it impossible for them to perform the contract.
Transfer of Assets to Avert Performance – If one parties transfer any business assets or properties, making it impossible to fulfill the contract.

The Indian judicial Approach towards Anticipatory Breach

Indian judicial pronouncements have recognized an anticipatory breach of contract. Courts evaluate:

If the breaching party had the intention.
Whether it is a Breach explicit or implicit.
The extent of losses suffered due to the breach.

Rights of the Non-Breaching Party in the Event of an Anticipatory Breach

In the event of an anticipatory breach, the non-breaching party is entitled to:

Right to terminate the contract – The non-breaching party has the right to immediately cancel the contract and pursue legal remedies.
Right to Wait Until Due Date – The non-breaching party has the option to wait until the date of performance to see if the breaching party reconsiders.
Right to Claim Damages — The aggrieved party is entitled to claim damages for the losses incurred as a result of the breach.

Solution to Anticipatory Breach

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 lays down the following legal remedies for anticipatory breach:

1. Damages

Compensatory Damages – Money to cover the monetary losses incurred due to non-performance.
Consequential Damages– Compensation for indirect losses such as loss of business opportunities.

2. Specific Performance

When damages are not sufficient, the court may order the breaching party to fulfill their contractual duties.

3. Injunctions

In cases where the anticipatory breach would involve acts that could cause irreparable harm, courts may issue injunctions that prevent the further acts.

4. Quantum Meruit

If partial performance of a contract has occurred, the non-breaching party is entitled to reasonable compensation for the work completed.

Landmark Judgements on Anticipatory Breach

Hochster v. De La Tour (1853) (English Case)

Established the doctrine of anticipatory breach in contract law.
Held that an aggrieved party may sue for breach before the due date of performance.

Indian Case Laws

Rajendra Singh v. State of U.P. (1981) – Established anticipatory breach and awarded damages to the aggrieved party.
Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co. (1954): Addressed anticipatory breach and enforced contract terms accordingly.

Anticipatory Breach vs. Actual Breach of Contract

While both types of breaches lead to failures to perform contractual obligations, they differ in timing, impact, and legal remedies available to the non-breaching party.

Differences Between Anticipatory Breach vs Actual Breach

Aspect	Anticipatory Breach	Actual Breach
Timing	Breach takes place when the party fails to perform at the agreed time.	Occurs when one Party fails to perform as agreed on or after the Due Date.
Nature of the Breach	It was justified based on a statement, action, or conduct showing an intention not to perform.	The non-breaching party can immediately cancel the contract and seek damages.
Legal Action	The non-breaching party can immediately cancel the contract and seek damages.	The non-breaching party can only sue after the due date.
Court Approach	Courts evaluate intent and action to find if the breach is anticipatory.	Courts assess whether the actual performance failed and award damages accordingly.
Example	A construction company, two months before the deadline, informs the client that they will not complete the project.	A supplier does not provide raw materials on the date agreed upon.

Legal Implications and Remedies for Anticipatory and Actual Breach

The legal remedies for anticipatory and actual breaches may vary depending on the nature of the breach and its impact on the parties.

For Anticipatory Breach:

The aggrieved party has the right to terminate the contract immediately and seek damages.
Alternatively, they can wait until the due date to see if the breaching party changes their mind and performs.
Courts can award compensatory damages for losses suffered due to non-performance.
In some cases, an injunction may be issued to prevent further damage.

For Actual Breach:

The non-breaching party can rescind the contract for non-performance.
They can recover damages to the extent of their financial losses.
The court may also, if permitted by the contract, order specific performance, which forces the breaching party to abide by the contract’s terms.

These differences help businesses and individuals respond quickly in the event of a breach to safeguard their legal and financial interests.

Preventing Anticipatory Breach in Business Contracts

A breach of contract can have significant financial implications on businesses and individuals. To mitigate risks, contracts should be well-drafted, regularly monitored, and include dispute resolution mechanisms.

1. Role of Clear Contractual Provisions

The first line of defense against anticipatory breach is a well-drafted contract. To prevent ambiguity, contracts should include:

Clearly defined rights and obligations of each party.
Performance deadlines with conditional clauses.

Provisions to identify early warning signs of non-performance. For instance, , a sales contract must specify delivery deadlines, payment terms, and penalties for non-delivery.

2. Adding Penalties and Dispute Resolution Mechanisms

To ensure compliance and provide an effective method of resolving disputes, contracts must include enforceable measures. Key clauses to include are:

Liquidated damages clause — Specifies financial penalties (if any) for failure to perform or breach of contract.
Force Majeure Clause – Protects parties in cases where performance becomes impossible due to unexpected events.
Dispute Resolution Clause — Outlines if disputes are to be settled with arbitration, mediation, or litigation.

For instance, a contract can contain a section that in case one of the parties expresses an unwillingness to fulfil its obligations, it shall be obliged to submit a written explanation within a 10-day period.

3. Regular Monitoring of the Contract and Communication Among Parties

Early signs of an anticipatory breach can be detected through proactive monitoring. Businesses can adopt the following strategies:

Regular Check-ins – Conduct periodic performance reviews to ensure compliance.
Early Intervention – Address potential non-performance issues before they escalate.
Written Communication – Maintain email, notice, and discussion logs as a record to track obligations and resolve disputes efficiently.

For instance, if a supplier regularly delays shipments, the buyer should communicate with the supplier early to assess whether an anticipatory breach is likely.

FAQs on Anticipatory Breach

1. Is it possible to rescind an anticipatory breach?

Yes, if the breaching party retracts their refusal before the non-breaching party takes legal action or terminates the contract, the agreement may remain valid.

2. What happens if both parties expect a breach?

Conclusion

Businesses and individuals need to understand the concept of anticipatory breach of contract in India before entering into any agreement. Adopting the risk avoidance strategies can minimize breach-of-contract risk, safeguard financial assets, and promote harmonious contractual relationships for businesses. Parties can achieve this, however, by identifying red-flags of breach, asserting in a legal manner, contractually allocated rights and seeking timely judicial remedies.

About Us

Corrida Legal is a boutique corporate & employment law firm serving as a strategic partner to businesses by helping them navigate transactions, fundraising-investor readiness, operational contracts, workforce management, data privacy, and disputes. The firm provides specialized and end-to-end corporate & employment law solutions, thereby eliminating the need for multiple law firm engagements. We are actively working on transactional drafting & advisory, operational & employment-related contracts, POSH, HR & data privacy-related compliances and audits, India-entry strategy & incorporation, statutory and labour law-related licenses, and registrations, and we defend our clients before all Indian courts to ensure seamless operations.

We keep our clients future-ready by ensuring compliance with the upcoming Indian Labour codes on Wages, Industrial Relations, Social Security, Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions – and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, of 2023. With offices across India including Gurgaon, Mumbai, and Delhi coupled with global partnerships with international law firms in Dubai, Singapore, the United Kingdom, and the USA, we are the preferred law firm for India entry and international business setups. Reach out to us on LinkedIn or contact us at contact@corridalegal.com/+91-8826680614 in case you require any legal assistance. Visit our publications page for detailed articles on contemporary legal issues and updates.