Introduction
Non-compete clauses are essential tools for businesses to safeguard trade secrets, intellectual property, and market position. They also help in preventing employees from engaging in unfair competition after leaving a company.
This article provides a comprehensive overview of non-compete clauses, including:
- What non-compete clauses are and why they are important
- The legal framework governing non-compete agreements
- Key Components of an enforceable Non-Compete Clause
- Common pitfalls in drafting non-compete clauses
- How to legally exit a non-compete agreement
- How Contract Management Software Can Help You with Non-Compete Clauses
After reading this article, you will get a clear understanding of how to draft enforceable non-compete clauses effectively.
Understanding Non-Compete Clauses
What is a Non-Compete Clause?
A non-compete clause is a contract provision that limits an employee from:
- Working for a direct competitor for a defined length of time, after he leaves the employer.
- Establishing their own business in the same industry or market segment.
- Competing through the use of trade secrets, client lists, or proprietary business information.
Such clauses protect investments in business, including the intellectual property involved and its market position.
Why Do Businesses Need Non-Compete Clauses?
Employers use non-compete agreements to:
- Prevent ex-employees from engaging in competitive practice;
- Protect sensitive trade secrets from leaking to competitors;
- To retain top employees and to discourage immediate hops to competitors;
- Safeguard the goodwill of businesses and their customers.
Common Industries Where Non-Compete Clauses Are Used
Non-competes are particularly pervasive among industries that depend on intellectual property, proprietary knowledge, and client trust, including:
- Technology & Software — Safeguards source codes, software creations, and trade secrets.
- Healthcare & Pharmaceuticals – Protects patient confidentiality and research data.
- Finance & Banking – Stops misusing sensitive financial strategies and client portfolios.
- Marketing & Advertising –Safeguard branding strategies, customer lists, and marketing plans.
Legal Framework Governing Non-Compete Clauses
Non-Compete Laws in India
In India, Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, of 1872 provides that any agreement that restricts trade or employment is void and unenforceable, thus post-employment non-compete clauses are generally unenforceable.
But there are exceptions:
- Non-competes are permissible during employment (e.g. if during employment, you don’t allow that employee to work for competitors while still employed).
- Agreements that protect trade secrets may be enforced in court.
- Under some circumstances, a limited non-compete agreement may be enforceable if the employer is paying some type of monetary consideration.
Comparison of Non-Compete Laws in Other Jurisdictions
| Country | Legal Position on Non-Compete Agreements |
| India | Non-competes that take effect after employment are typically invalid. |
| United States | Depending on state law; California prohibits non-compete agreements, Texas enforces reasonable limitations. |
| United Kingdom | Non-competes are permissible if they are necessary and reasonable. |
| European Union | Heavily regulated; needs justification and compensation. |
How to Draft a Non-Compete Agreement?
A sound non-compete agreement should be:
1. Clearly Defined
- Specify what the agreement is for.
- Identify what competition means (industry, job role).
2. Reasonable in Duration
- The average term of enforceable non-competes ranges between 6 months to 2 years.
- Courts tend to invalidate deals that run longer than is necessary.
3. Limited in Geographic Scope
- A non-compete should only cover the territories in which the employer conducts business.
- A worldwide or national ban would probably be unenforceable.
4. Compensation for the Employee
- Courts in this context are more likely to find a non-compete agreement enforceable when the employer also provides some consideration, such as:
- Severance pay
- Paid restriction period (garden leave)
- Stock options or bonuses
Essential Elements of an enforceable Non-Compete Clause
To be enforceable, a non-compete should have:
1. Duration of Restriction
- 6 months to 2 years is considered a reasonable time by courts.
- Longer restrictions (for more than 2 years) are often challenged in court.
- Must correlate with the time to safeguard business interests (i.e. client turnover rate).
2. Geographic Scope
- Must be narrowly tailored e.g., prohibiting competition in the same municipality or state.
- Restrictive clauses with overbroad geographical restrictions (e.g., “anywhere in India”) are generally unenforceable.
- Courts consider if the employee’s job involves nationwide expertise.
3. Scope of Restricted Activities
- Competitors (defined narrowly — e.g., a competing SaaS company).
- Must not entirely prevent employees from working in the field.
- Restrict bans to whole industries — instead, narrowed by task or role.
4. Consideration & Compensation
- Giving monetary benefits makes a non-compete more enforceable.
- Some companies pay their employees during the garden leave/employment restriction period.
How to Exit a Non-Compete Agreement?
When employees are looking to challenge or negotiate their non-compete agreements, they can:
1. Negotiate with the Employer
- Propose returning trade secrets or be subjected to partial restriction.
2. Challenge the Non-Compete in Court
- Claim that the clause is unduly sweeping.
- Shows that it is limiting the right to earn a living.
How to Draft a Non-Compete Clause Using Contract Management Software?
Contract management software allows businesses to generate legally compliant non-compete agreements by:
- Getting pre-approved legal templates ready to be filled in.
- Automated contract compliance with jurisdictional laws.
- Eliminating manual errors in employment contracts.
Some of the key contractor’s management platforms are:
- Ironclad
- DocuSign CLM
- Contract Works
Common Non-Compete Drafting Pitfalls to Avoid
Employers often insert non-compete clauses in employment contracts on a whim, without sufficient regard for how enforceable or fair the contracts might be. That can result in legal disputes, employee unhappiness, and, in many cases, the court striking the clause completely. Some of the common pitfalls companies make when creating non-compete agreements include:
1. Overly Broad Restrictions
This is one of the most common reasons non-compete clauses don’t hold up in court — they are too broad in time, geography, and/or scope of restriction. Employers must not do the following:
- Overbroad Time Limitations: A court will not enforce a non-compete for multiple years. The period is between 6 months to 2 years.
- Generalized geographic constraints: Courts usually find it unreasonable to prevent an employee from working anywhere in an entire country or for a particular industry. This restriction may be better limited to areas in which the business operates.
- Broad job function prohibitions: A good non-compete agreement identifies which work job function types are limited by the non-compete and does not prevent an employee from working in that entire industry.
2. Not Doing Business Needs Justification
Employers will have to show a bona fide business interest sufficient to justify the non-compete. Courts are hesitant to enforce non-competes that seem arbitrary or overbearing. Legal business interests include:
- Keeping private proprietary knowledge safe.
- Protecting client relationships.
- Protecting proprietary business processes.
If a company cannot show that a non-compete is essential for a business purpose, courts will generally rule it out.
3. Not Offering Consideration or Compensation
A non-compete clause is likely to be valid if the employee receives consideration (compensation or other benefits) for agreeing to the restriction. Non-competes that are not subject to sufficient consideration will be unenforceable in many jurisdictions. Some options include:
- Offering a cash incentive for signing the agreement.
- Salary continuation through the non-compete period.
- Compensating with stock options or bonuses.
4. Not Tailoring the Agreement to Specific Employees
A boilerplate competition is probably not going to be enforceable in court. Such restrictions should be tailored to the particular employee’s job function, access to sensitive information, and the employer’s actual competitive concerns.
So, a non-compete for a senior executive with access to corporate strategy will have a broader scope than one for an entry-level employee with little confidential knowledge.
5. Ignoring Jurisdictional Laws
Non-compete laws vary by state and country. For instance, post-employment non-compete clauses are generally not enforceable in India, while they are enforceable under specific circumstances in some U.S. states. Employers should always seek legal guidance to ensure that their contracts are compliant with applicable law.
Validity and Enforceability in the Court
There are three tests that courts typically use to test non-compete agreements:
1. Test of Legitimate Business Interest
Courts evaluate whether the non-compete serves a legitimate business interest. Examples include:
- Intangible Assets: Trade Secrets and Confidential Information.
- Training specific to the job offered by the employer.
- Business Relationships are built during employment.
Chances are if the clause is simply there to avoid competition without a good reason the clause will not be enforceable.
2. Reasonableness Test
What exactly is the Non-Compete trying to protect?
- The duration of restriction.
- This restriction applies on a geographic basis.
- The impact on the employee’s ability to earn a livelihood.
Any one of these may be enough to invalidate the clause.
3. Public Interest Test
Some courts look at whether enforcing the non-compete would serve the public interest. In some industries, enforcing a non-compete may be unenforceable because the non-compete clause would limit someone’s access to necessary specialty doctors such as in healthcare.
FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions About Non-Compete Clauses
1. Are non-compete clauses legal in India?
Non-compete clauses are enforceable during employment. However, post-employment non-compete clauses are usually unenforceable under section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
2. How long should a non-compete last?
In general, 6 months to 2 years is a fair time frame based on the industry.
3. What if an employee breaches a non-compete clause?
Employers can pursue legal lawsuits, injunctions, or monetary damages.
Conclusion
Non-Compete clause in an agreement is a must for business if drafted correctly, however, overreaching non-competes may be unenforceable and can be subject to legal challenges. Employers should ensure that the non-compete clauses are:
- Reasonable duration and geography are security requirements.
- Allow for enforceability with compensation.
- Flag for alternative legal protections when appropriate.
About Us
Corrida Legal is a boutique corporate & employment law firm serving as a strategic partner to businesses by helping them navigate transactions, fundraising-investor readiness, operational contracts, workforce management, data privacy, and disputes. The firm provides specialized and end-to-end corporate & employment law solutions, thereby eliminating the need for multiple law firm engagements. We are actively working on transactional drafting & advisory, operational & employment-related contracts, POSH, HR & data privacy-related compliances and audits, India-entry strategy & incorporation, statutory and labour law-related licenses, and registrations, and we defend our clients before all Indian courts to ensure seamless operations.
We keep our clients future-ready by ensuring compliance with the upcoming Indian Labour codes on Wages, Industrial Relations, Social Security, Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions – and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, of 2023. With offices across India including Gurgaon, Mumbai, and Delhi coupled with global partnerships with international law firms in Dubai, Singapore, the United Kingdom, and the USA, we are the preferred law firm for India entry and international business setups. Reach out to us on LinkedIn or contact us at contact@corridalegal.com/+91-8826680614 in case you require any legal assistance. Visit our publications page for detailed articles on contemporary legal issues and updates.